
When it comes time to upgrade your bathroom, there are many things you may consider updating. Many homeowners worry about increasing their storage space, changing out old tile, or making the space easier to navigate. But, as you begin planning, it may also be a good time to think about whether a walk-in shower or bathtub is right for your bathroom.
Each comes with benefits, and it is important to understand each to determine which is the best addition to your bathroom. Whether you’re upgrading your primary suite or a guest bathroom, it can be tough to choose between walk-in showers and bathtubs. In this blog, we’ll explore the benefits of each to help you make the best decision for your home.
Why Choose a Walk-In Shower?
If you are considering investing in a walk-in shower, there are many benefits to investing in one for your bathroom, including:
- Improved Accessibility: One of the most significant benefits of investing in a walk-in shower is the increased accessibility. With a short lip separating your shower enclosure from the tile floors, you don’t have to worry about swinging a leg over a taller bathtub rim, making it a great choice for aging adults and individuals with mobility challenges.
- Modern Appearance: Older bathrooms may have small bathtubs and shower stalls that aren’t quite as spacious as you’d like. As you prepare for your bathroom upgrade, you can trust that investing in a newer, larger shower stall can help you achieve a more modern, sleek appearance for your newly renovated space.
- Increased Home Value: Many potential homebuyers love the luxury and convenience of a beautiful, custom shower enclosure. While you might not be considering selling your home for years to come, choosing to upgrade your bathroom with a more luxurious shower stall can boost your home value when you finally list it.
- Fits Every Bathroom: Walk-in showers come in all shapes and sizes, which is what makes them a perfect choice for a variety of bathrooms. Whether you’re squeezing one into a small shared bathroom or creating a large shower enclosure for your primary suite, they’re the perfect choice.
Is a Bathtub Right for Your Home?
While there are many benefits to investing in a walk-in shower for your bathroom, you may love the luxury and comfort of a bathtub. Some of the benefits of installing a new bathtub in your bathroom include:

- Luxurious Bathroom Escape: If you love winding down at the end of a busy workday, a shower may not be enough for you. In that case, investing in a large, comfortable soaking tub is the perfect solution. A bathtub allows you to create the perfect spa-like escape where you can comfortably end your day.
- Family Convenience: When you have young children in the house, not having a bathtub can be a bit of a dealbreaker. Ensuring you have a bathtub in your bathroom can make it much easier to help children through their bathtime, especially if you are bathing children under three years of age who still can’t shower on their own.
- Muscle Relief: Whether you’re a competitive athlete or spend several days a week in the gym, you want to ensure you’re doing everything in your power to soothe your aching muscles. With a bathtub, you can increase blood flow, allowing your muscles to recover more quickly from intense workouts.
- Improved Sleep: Soaking in a bathtub at the end of the day is a great way to raise your core temperature, especially during the colder winter months. As your core temperature drops, you naturally become sleepy, which can help you fall asleep faster and get better sleep throughout the night.
Should You Consider a Walk-In Tub?
If you’re unsure whether a walk-in shower or tub is right, you might want to consider alternatives. For homeowners facing mobility challenges or seeking the ultimate blend of safety and comfort, a walk-in tub is a compelling option that bridges the gap between a standard tub and a walk-in shower.
One of the greatest advantages is the safety and accessibility they offer. Featuring a low threshold and a watertight door, these tubs eliminate the high step-over associated with traditional models, drastically reducing the risk of falls, a primary concern for older adults. Once inside, you can sit comfortably on a built-in seat while the tub fills.

Walk-in tubs also offer therapeutic benefits. Many models come equipped with hydrotherapy jets, creating a spa-like experience that can soothe aching muscles and joints, improve circulation, and alleviate symptoms of arthritis or chronic pain. This soaking therapy is often preferred over a simple shower for deep relaxation and muscle recovery.
While they require more space than some smaller walk-in showers and come with a higher initial investment, a walk-in tub can significantly enhance the quality of life and independence for those who wish to continue enjoying the therapeutic comfort of a bath in their own home.
How Much Should You Budget for Your Bathroom Remodel?
Establishing a realistic budget is a critical first step for any bathroom renovation, as costs can fluctuate dramatically based on scope, materials, and labor. While a minor refresh, such as updating fixtures and paint, might cost as little as $5,000, a complete overhaul of a primary bathroom often falls into the $15,000 to $25,000 range.
To budget effectively, consider these factors:
- Size and Scope: Remodeling a small guest bath is significantly cheaper than renovating a large primary suite that includes moving plumbing or electrical lines.
- Material Quality: Choosing luxury finishes, like custom tile or high-end walk-in shower systems, will drive up costs faster than standard, off-the-shelf options.
- Labor: Professional installation can account for 40-60% of the total budget.

Turn Your Dream Bathroom Into Reality
When you’re ready to transform your bathroom into your dream in-home oasis, turn to our team at Surface Bella for support. Whether a bathtub or walk-in shower is right for you, we’re dedicated to turning your bathroom dreams into reality. No matter what plans you have for this space, we will help you improve its appearance, storage space, and more.
If you would like to schedule a bathroom remodel for your Greenville home, don’t hesitate to reach out to us to schedule a no-obligation consultation.
